Nobody Wants Artisanal Code Anymore

(gordonbeeming.com)

17 points | by Bluestein 1 hour ago

11 comments

  • tom_ 57 minutes ago
    Apparently nobody wants artisanal writing either!
    • spacechild1 43 minutes ago
      Nor artisanal web design.
    • jimbob88 39 minutes ago
      Imagine getting the first draft of this back from Claude and saying “Great, now make it 3x longer.”
  • tagalog 58 minutes ago
    I bounced at the first load-bearing use of load-bearing.
    • Bluestein 57 minutes ago
      It is very obviously AI ... assisted, to whatever degree. Still, makes valid points methinks.-
      • ActionHank 53 minutes ago
        Honestly, no it’s not, it’s an echo from the echo chamber. There is no original thought here.
  • dofm 52 minutes ago
    This is exhausting and would have been a lot easier to read in the more, how to put it, natural writing style the author had until early 2025.

    What changed, I wonder? ;-/

  • apt-apt-apt-apt 43 minutes ago
    Huge bloated article that unclearly expresses a simple thought.

    It's like the author prompted, "write me a big article on what is and isn't a commodity with AI, and make it confusing"

    • karmakurtisaani 31 minutes ago
      "If I have a blog with long posts, I'll be a thought leader."

      Such pre-LLM thinking, can't believe it's still a thing.

  • flossly 38 minutes ago
    We need down-vote buttons for slop like this on HN. How can this reach the frontpage?

    Since you are reading, here a story of mine. Both me and a friend build a SaaS product using ClaudeCode. We both have 15+ year experience in software (he more in dotNET me more in FLOSS).

    He just accepted everything it came up with (pretty much vibe). I was suuuuuuper careful about what I accepted and spend the first weeks programming a lot myself.

    His stack for JS was HUUUGE. Several different technologies were used. Mine JS stack was: only use Alpine.js (and avoid JS as much as possible).

    His backend stack was equally huge: lots of native/binary OS dependencies bundled in Docker. Mine was 13MB of libs on top of the JVM.

    Being one year in I run 3500 tests in 20secs. App boots under 3secs.

    He considers rewriting it.

    The art(isanal) is still important. Sure it's different now. But MY GOD what a difference a bit of oversight/leadership/tech-vision can make.

    • olmo23 31 minutes ago
      > We need down-vote buttons for slop like this on HN. How can this reach the frontpage?

      LinkedIn introduced a "Seems like AI slop" reporting option, perhaps we should consider asking for one for HN too?

  • ActionHank 56 minutes ago
    This is so stupid.

    Can an accountant make a CRM in a weekend? Sure.

    Will it be there next week? Maybe, probably not.

    Building software was never, not even once, about writing code. That’s easy, literally anyone can do it.

    It’s about building something that lasts beyond needing to be completely refactored.

  • bbg2401 23 minutes ago
    I'm glad frontend design skills have moved us away from the generic, inoffensive font families of yesteryear towards the likes of Space Grotesk and a smattering of IBM Plex Mono in places ill-suited to monospace families.
  • Madmallard 59 minutes ago
    First it was "The End of Programming" two hours ago.

    Now this one. Lol

    • kodoman 58 minutes ago
      Nobody wants human written prose (or maybe even thoughts as well) any more apparently.
      • Retr0id 57 minutes ago
        To be fair I'm not sure HN ever wanted prose in the first place, usually just a headline will do.
    • pluc 58 minutes ago
      First it was that article about how 60℅ of HN posts were AI generated
    • Bluestein 58 minutes ago
      I really, honestly think the writeup goes beyond the headline and is well worth the read and the time.-
  • boesboes 53 minutes ago
    And I don't want your blog-slop vomit
  • lensecat 46 minutes ago
    If you're gonna slop-write your blog post at least put in the same effort you urge people to make when writing code...
  • Citizen_Lame 44 minutes ago
    Pot, kettle, something. Karma bot pointing to AI written article complaining about lack of artisanal code.