11 comments

  • VTimofeenko 5 minutes ago
    When picking out a jackshaft garage door opener a couple of years ago, I went out of my way not to get anything that has MyQ. Overhead Garage Door (the company) stocks what they refer to as Odyssey 2000, and it comes with an optional WiFi module, which I skipped. The opener is more than happy to just toggle open/close state if the contacts are momentarily bridged.

    I paired it with Zen17, though in hindsight I could have just gone with an esp32 hidden right next to the motor.

    Open/closed state is reported by a separate tilt sensor, which I might also swap for something else if only not to have to swap yet another battery

  • DannyBee 5 hours ago
    Chamberlain actively fights all attempts at third parties buildnig tools to control/monitor/use their garage door openers so they can sell subscriptions.

    Giving them money in the first place is a horrible idea.

    • thereader12 3 hours ago
      I wonder why they spend the effort. It seems like the people willing to pay and people willing to hack are different. With the hackers be a small group anyway
      • bugrasan 2 hours ago
        [dead]
      • denkmoon 1 hour ago
        Same reason any other company lawyers up when a handful of nerds modify the hardware they bought and own - it gets some suity dude's nose out of joint.
    • jamesjhare 2 hours ago
      They're asking for legislation to address their predatory practices about as hard as you can. If I buy a garage door opener I should own access to it without the bullshit.

      Had to get a new garage door opener because the old one stopped working. Got a MyQ opener because it seemed like an excellent choice. Now my car wants me to pay for a subscription to open the door and the remotes that came with the damn thing have super-short range.

      On top of that I live less than a mile from an airport directly in the descent path so there is basically 0 mobile service at my home. Often the MyQ app fails to function at all.

      My old garage door opener got the damn thing open every time without issue. Would love to have it back.

    • ninkendo 5 hours ago
      Sometimes you get what the installer has in stock, I didn’t really “pick” Chamberlain, it’s just what the guy put in when I paid him to “fix my garage door”. For a lot of other people it’s just what comes with the house.

      The correct answer is to just let your garage door opener be dumb, and buy a RatGDO, which works with any dumb opener including chamberlains: https://ratcloud.llc/

      I like to think chamberlain sells their openers at a slightly lower price than they otherwise would, hoping to recover it on subscriptions. So by buying their opener plus a RatGDO, I’m hurting their bottom line just a tiny amount. It makes me feel good at least.

      • graton 4 hours ago
        Unfortunately Chamberlain Security + 3.0 openers are not supported. If I ever need to replace my current garage door opener I will be looking for a non-Chamberlain product.

        https://ratcloud.llc/pages/frequently-asked-questions

      • dalyons 4 hours ago
        Unfortunately new chamberlains now come with Security 3.0, which is designed to lock out ratgdo and everything else, probably forever. So you’re kind of screwed if you’ve bought one recently.
      • yegle 2 hours ago
        I never understand the appeal of RatGDO. You can find other tools like Shelly 1 that can be easily integrated into your existing Zigbee/Matter ecosystem, or part of the Home Assistant via the HTTP interface, and they are much cheaper with proper UL certification.
        • ryandrake 2 hours ago
          You don’t have to buy the expensive official ratgdo device. The ratgdo software is free and you can build a small PCB for a few bucks plus the cost of the ESP32 and a couple of components. My house unfortunately came with MyQ openers so that’s what I’m doing.
    • dalyons 37 minutes ago
      there are no workarounds or options for their new security 3.0 models, you are just screwed. Their subscription or nothing. Just dont buy a Chamberlain/liftmaster.

      Guess why this happened, to a brand with a previously stellar reputation? yep they got bought by PE.

  • whatever1 4 hours ago
    Get from Amazon a robo finger that presses buttons and have it press your garage door switch
  • Namidairo 4 hours ago
    If they didn't bother flipping the security flag in OTP to disable JTAG, then one has to wonder whether they even used secure boot and signed images.

    One could just end up repacking the image with their own certificate chain, or patching out the reboot itself.

    • ranger_danger 4 hours ago
      Or point an LLM at the firmware and get a nice decompilation project going. Or totally custom firmware.
  • don-code 5 hours ago
    I'm happy it's possible, but I'm not sure if I'm sufficiently happy to offset the fact that it's necessary.

    This also makes me wonder why it's necessary. What requirement were they trying to solve for? Does lack of Internet connectivity mask some bigger problem with the firmware on the device periodically needing a restart?

    • jedbrooke 4 hours ago
      I wonder if the thought process is something like: 1. device should have internet connection if it’s working properly

      2. no internet connection means it’s not working properly

      3. reboot usually fixes things

      4. therefore, if no internet connection, we should reboot.

      Of course 1 and 2 are the real issue, I wish device makers would design devices that treat internet connectivity as always optional.

      • thereader12 3 hours ago
        Apparently they are actively fighting users who try to do local connections. It's just open malice this time.
  • Polizeiposaune 5 hours ago
    Ditching the MyQ and buying a ratgdo seems lots easier.
    • dalyons 4 hours ago
      Unfortunately new chamberlains now come with Security 3.0, which is designed to lock out ratgdo and everything else, probably forever. So you’re kind of screwed if you are getting one today
      • darknavi 1 hour ago
        Never doubt persistent nerds (now with LLMs!).

        Similar to media piracy, I've never seen a more motivated group of individuals to seize and automate.

        Frankly it's lovely. You'll never beat passion like that.

    • gavinsyancey 4 hours ago
      Unless you're outside the return window and don't want to buy a new thing to replace working hardware.
  • kusha 2 days ago
    A bit of context that didn't make it into the writeup:

    The 819LMB is a HomeKit based device, meaning by HomeKit spec it is supposed to function 100% locally on your LAN with zero internet access. (most connect it to home assistant)

    In their infinite wisdom, Chamberlain decided to cripple it anyway: if the garage door opener cannot reach their cloud, a firmware watchdog triggers a hard reboot every 30 minutes, taking down local HomeKit control along with it. Additionally, if you don't block the internet the right way, it reboots every 10 minutes in addition to the 30 minute reboot.

    • evulhotdog 1 hour ago
      Shouldn’t this negate their HomeKit certification? Seems like something Apple would care about, when using their formal names on things.
  • jmbwell 1 hour ago
    There’s so little to these machines. Seems like an open source PCB to replace the proprietary would be feasible. Relays, limit switch inputs, obstruction sensors, current sensors, control input. Commodity stuff. I’m sure chamberlain is doing everything they can to make it seem more mystical than it is. Just to make number go up I suppose
  • tonymet 5 hours ago
    very cool work. Clearly Chamberlain is very poor at writing software interfaces. I’ve witnessed duplicate closure commands that almost damaged my vehicle. There are many customers with damage due to MyQ on Reddit.

    I now only use MyQ as a last resort.

  • ProAm 4 hours ago
    My g-d I hate the MyQ software with a passion. Nothing works on it consistently except for the ads they show. Two-factor auth? You're going to have to do it multiple times. Set your security preferences, they'll reset them at will. Notifications about the garage door being open, closed, etc.... More like we'll notify you about ads and things we want to sell.
  • doctorpangloss 4 hours ago
    do the Bosch Smart e-bike system next

    God what fucking fuckwads